As a journalist and true crime podcaster who investigates unsolved murders, people at cocktail parties often ask me if I carry a gun.

But I have another, much better, secret weapon: He weighs six pounds, has zero concept of his own mortality, and looks like he should be coated in concrete and attached to the side of a Gothic building.

His name is Winston. He;โ€™s a Chihuahua with unexplained alopecia, and it turns out that a pocket-sized canine with the physique of an undernourished supermarket rotisserie chicken is the ultimate forensic skeleton key.

When Winston and I were knocking on strange doors in small towns while I was working on my new book, How to Survive a Murder Investigation (Ballantine), people didnโ€™t see a journalist and licensed private investigator hunting for a killer. They saw a tall woman walking a tiny dog in desperate need of a potty break.

I take my cues from Jessica Fletcher on Murder, She Wrote. Jessica was a mystery novelist of a certain age who wore cardigans, asked seemingly innocent questions, and somehow solved murders that had completely baffled local police. Her greatest advantage, apart from a razor-sharp mind, was that nobody considered her particularly threatening. While the detectives were busy looking for someone suspicious, Jessica was already in the kitchen having coffee with the person who knew exactly what happened.

Winston and I have adopted a similar approach. Because nobody suspects the Chihuahua. As a private investigator and a journalist, I canโ€™t force people to talk to meโ€”I have to make them want to tell me their darkest secrets. These are two entirely different skill sets. In PI school, when learning how to canvass a neighborhood, we were taught a ruse involving a lost dog poster. My instructor told me that even the most hardened criminals melt in the face of a small animal. People automatically become guarded the second they think they are being interrogated, but while they are busy looking down at my dog, I am looking for an opening.

Winston was riding along when we showed up at the Possum Trot gas station in Melbourne, Arkansasโ€“the last place twenty-two-year-old college student Rebekah Gould was seen alive in September of 2004, buying a sugary cappuccino in her pajama bottoms and fuzzy slippers.

When her body was found a week later off a remote highway embankment near Devilโ€™s Knob, a heavy, protective silence settled over those mountains. Local law enforcement quickly wrote her off as a โ€œhigh-risk victim,โ€ and for sixteen years, the investigation stalled.

Everyone told me a lone woman couldnโ€™t make headway where the Arkansas State Police had spent over a decade hitting walls. So, I packed up my life in New York City, loaded Winston into his black pet carrier, and headed back to the Ozarks to immerse myself in the case.ย 

He was riding shotgun when I tracked down a close friend of Rebekahโ€™s boyfriend to ask sensitive questions about the blood-soaked trailer where the murder took place. When I showed up at his workplace out of the blue, I knew the stakes: I might only have one single shot at getting him to speak to me. At first, when I asked if we could talk, he hesitated. But right on cue, Winston stuck his hairless head out of the zipper bag and pricked up his large ears. That was my opening. As we sat in the back office flipping through old memories, Winston sat on my lap acting like a natural buffer. Every time an uncomfortable question came up, his presence deflected the tension.

Winston isnโ€™t a watchdog; he mostly just growls softly from his carrier when he senses my unease. He couldn’t fend off an attacker, but he gives me something much more crucial: unending emotional support. As I say in my bookโ€™s dedication section, he is my constant canine companion who ensures that I never have to investigate alone.

Neither of us fits the traditional expectation of what a homicide investigator should look like. I am a former dating columnist turned detective, and he is a dog who lives inside a handbag. But this case taught me to embrace the power of being completely overlooked and underestimated.ย 

How to Survive a Murder Investigation is the raw, unfiltered blueprint of that journey. It is part investigative memoir and part real-world survival manual for anyone who has ever looked at a systemic injustice and absolutely refused to back down. The people in power may look down on women who rock cardigans, or mistake our politeness for weakness, or believe (wrongly) that a tiny dog on a leash canโ€™t be fierce.ย But weโ€™re already in the room, getting answers.


Catherine Townsend is a journalist, private investigator, and podcaster. She is the host of the iHeartMedia podcast Hell and Gone and Red Collar. After beginning her career as a staff writer for New York magazine, Catherine moved to London to create The Independentโ€™s very popular โ€œSleeping Aroundโ€ dating column. Her articles have appeared in publications including The Atlantic, Elle, New York, GQ, Marie Claire, Cosmopolitan, The Daily Mail, The New York Post, Investigation Discovery, and HuffPost. She became a licensed private investigator in 2013.