While You Were Screaming/Shailee Thompson

Gallery Books/February 9, 2027

Shailee Thompson’s debut comedy thriller, How to Kill a Guy in Ten Dates, used horror movie tropes and references as the feisty and funny Laurie Hamilton fought to survive speed-dating-turned-slasher-movie. In her sophomore novel, While You Were Screaming, Thompson tries to re-create the same magic but this one doesn’t hit the same.

After surviving speed dating, Laurie suffers a death knoll to her career when legal complications halt her film project about that night. She’s stuck in a dead-end, unfulfilling job that involves creating filler content until her former professor reaches out with a lifeline–an opportunity to expose the Kindred Souls couples retreat as a cult by going undercover in an anticipated documentary series.

Of course, Laurie can’t go undercover at a couples retreat without the other half of a couple. To her dismay, this is Connor Kincaid, a sexy former podcaster and Laurie’s nemesis/almost boyfriend during their younger years in college. Since graduating nearly a decade ago, Connor’s career seems to have flourished while Laurie’s has stagnated, which is a major sore spot considering their constant competition in college. But, with no other job prospects available and the carrot of participating in a documentary production dangling before her, Laurie acquiesces.

Connor and Laurie infiltrate the outrageously expensive Kindred Souls in the Catskills, where they are forced to pose as a loving couple despite friction beneath the surface. They meet the other couples, including an endearing gay male couple and another where one partner is much more invested in the relationship than the other. Connor and Laurie struggle to fit in while searching for signs of Kindred Souls indeed being a cult, with Thompson helpfully signposting with chapter prefaces featuring cult-related facts and anecdotes.

The story’s focus then starts to meander. Connor and Laurie are at Kindred Souls to uncover a cult, but what kind of cult are we looking at here? Do they expect to find violence? The drinking of tainted Kool-Aid after the signing away of all worldly possessions? There’s no real mystery or sense of impending danger, just hijinks as Laurie and Connor investigate with little progress. Surely, the duo’s experience will lead to a revelation or exposure of the cult’s true intentions, but its nature isn’t clear.

Then there’s the bubbling sexual tension between Laurie and Connor as they co-exist in cramped living quarters. It’s inevitable they’re going to end up together. Not even a question. The two challenge one another in the best way, and it’s only too obvious how this romantic comedy ends. Unless, of course, one of them ends up dead. But again, it isn’t clear if this possibility is on the table.

How to Kill a Guy in Ten Dates was incredibly fun because of how Woodland leaned into horror movie rules and tropes as her lead character–named, like so many others in the book, after the ultimate Final Girl, Laurie Strode–navigated danger and bodies. With the setup of that first novel, it seemed that this one would follow a similar outline using romantic comedy rules and character stereotypes as the foundation. It doesn’t, despite the perfect setting of a couples retreat.

That’s not to say there aren’t fun elements. Laurie is still a great character, and the idea of making up for a missed romantic opportunity–especially with a rascal like Connor–is tantalizing. There are plenty of entertaining scenes at the couples retreat/cult. It simply lacks direction–what kind of documentary will this be? Are our main characters in real danger?

While You Were Screaming may not live up to How to Kill a Guy in Ten Dates, but its heroine is worthy of following around for a second time.

*About the reviewer: A writer of dark comedy thrillers, Sarah Reida is currently seeking representation for her sophomore novel, Murder Boat. Her  debut, Neighborhood Watch, received a Kirkus Star and was honored as an Amazon editorial pick as one of the Best Books of the Year So Far 2024. Join Sarah’s elite group of Instagram followers here.